The SPCA's Violence Link Project: Helping Victims of Violence? It Sounds Good on Paper But is the SPCA really DOING Anything?
Go to...AAS's investigation of the SPCA's "violence Link Project" and our findings

Posted By: Jeri-Lyn Ratzlaff, Jennifer Dickson, Judy Stone: AAS
Date: Tuesday, 25 May 2004, at 2:15 p.m.

In November of 2003, the BC SPCA announced that it had partnered with several BC organizations to create the "Violence Link Project", a program designed to inform and aid the pets of victims of violence. The BC SPCA's role was described as being both an educator of the public as well as a support system for victims of abuse and their pets. It all sounded wonderful on paper, and a series of pamphlets was created to promote the program. The BC SPCA also issued a press release touting all that it was doing to help victims of violence and their pets.

Following is a brief synopsis of what the program claims to offer, taken directly from pamphlets, websites, and BC SPCA press releases:

From the BCSPCA’s November 19, 2003 Press Release “Addressing the Link Between Family Violence and Animal Cruelty”

”The Violence Link Project officially launches Nov. 19th with the first joint training workshop at the Justice Institute of BC. Participants from several BC agencies and organizations will gather to increase their knowledge about the link between family violence and animal abuse and to share information on identifying signs of abuse. A series of brochures on the violence link has also been produced for wide distribution by organizations helping victims of violence.”

Excerpts from Pamphlet #1 for the General Public

“Support anyone who may be abused by a family member. Encourage the person to call VictimLINK at 1-800-563-0808.”

“Report animal abuse. Report all instances of suspected animal abuse to the BC SPCA or police.”

Excerpts from Pamphlet #2 for Animal Care Professionals: Coordinating Violence Prevention

“Today, communities across Canada are initiating coalitions for coordinated violence prevention. Animal care workers, family violence workers and police officers are learning how to recognize and report cross-abuse.

Examples of current collaborative work:

- including plans for pets in safety plans for abused women

- developing emergency shelter programs for the pets of women leaving abusive relationships

- including animal care workers on local coordinating committees for violence against women in relationships

- building partnerships between veterinarians and family violence prevention workers

- developing training modules on violence against women in relationships, animal abuse, and child abuse for animal protection workers and family violence prevention workers

- having family violence courses in colleges and universities that include pets in the definition of family

- holding joint educational workshops for the family violence prevention and animal welfare communities

Resources

- The BC SPCA is taking practical steps to address the training needs about the link between animal abuse and family violence. The BC SPCA is also working with local communities to provide support to battered women and their pets.

Excerpts from Pamphlet #3 for Victim Service Workers and Justice System Personnel

“Be informed about the links between family violence and animal abuse, the resources you can use, and the collaborative efforts underway in your community.

-Report Abuse

Report suspected child abuse. Call the Helpline for Children 310-1234 (toll free, no area code needed)

Report suspected animal abuse the SPCA or the police. Phone BC SPCA: 1-800-665-1868”

“-Become Involved

Contact Victim Services Division to find out more about resources, cross-training, the development of protocols, and community coalitions. Phone: 604-660-5199.

· The BC/Yukon Society of Transition Houses is working with the BC SPCA and with veterinarians in local communities to provide support for battered women and their pets. BC SPCA toll free: 1-800-665-1868

· The British Columbia Veterinary Medical Association has made animal welfare, including animal abuse, one of its priorities. Contact the British Columbia Veterinary Medical Association at 1-604-929-7090.

· BC /Yukon Society of Transition Houses: 604-669-6943.”

Resource links for all 3 brochures www.bcifv.org www.bcysth.ca www.spca.bc.ca www.bcvma.org  From the BC SPCA's website: www.bcspca/abuse.htm

Towards a Humane Coalition
“Every year, the BC SPCA conducts over 10,000 cruelty investigations, while Social Services responds to some 30,000 allegations of child abuse or neglect. Although only a small percentage of investigations uncovers serious abuse, it is clear that the community -- and families at risk -- would be well served by earlier intervention arising from interagency cooperation. In an escalating situation, animals are often the first victims. Because they fear intervention will result in removal of the children, neighbours may report concerns about animal cruelty sooner than acting upon suspicions of child abuse. Recognizing this, the SPCA has begun to train its inspectors in child abuse detection.”

From the BC SPCA's online magazine Animal Sense:

http://www.spca.bc.ca/animalsense/FallWinter2002/ViolenceLinkFallWinter2002.htm

Excerpts from “The Pattern of Violence: The links between human and animal abuse are well documented and the BC SPCA is out to help victims of violence and their pets.” by Gail Johnson

"Research points to a link between cruelty to animals and family abuse.

The good news is that a number of local initiatives are in the works to educate people about the connection — and to help both victims of abuse and their pets.

“We want to raise awareness about the link and let people know there are services available,” says Craig Naherniak, the general manager of humane education at the BC SPCA. “Animals are part of that equation. We want to help victims of abuse find a safe way to leave.”

One of the most difficult things a woman can do is leave an abusive relationship — and many may not leave sooner out of fear for their pet’s safety.

A 1998 survey conducted by the Ontario SPCA looked at women leaving

abusive relationships and found that 61 per cent had pets abused or killed by their partners. Forty-eight per cent said that concern over the safety of their pets prevented them from leaving sooner.

Here is where things get complicated. Many transition houses do not allow pets. Often, women are advised to leave their animal with a friend or family member, but many do not want to put their loved ones in a dangerous situation. The B.C./Yukon Society of Transition Houses recently completed a survey on clients and their pets and found that 86 per cent of transition houses had a no-pet policy.

In response, the Transition House Society has developed the Companion Animals Research and Education Initiative, which aims to provide shelters for battered women with resources to help those with pets. Funded by the Vancouver Foundation and the Animal Welfare Foundation of Canada, CARE’s Tool Kit will include information such as signs of animal abuse and information for developing pet foster programs.

The Transition House Society has teamed up with the SPCA in certain areas of B.C. and the Yukon to enable women to leave their pets at shelters while they are in transition homes. “There are solutions,” says Harrison. “We can help women who have nowhere to turn to keep them and their pets safe.”

To help the public better understand the link between animal and domestic violence, the BC SPCA is publishing educational brochures, produced jointly with the B.C. government’s Victim Services Branch, the UBC School of Social Work, the B.C. Veterinary Medical Association, the Institute Against Family Violence and the B.C./Yukon Transition House Society. Funded in part by the federal government’s National Crime Prevention Centre, the pamphlets will be distributed locally throughout B.C. A series of workshops on community- coalition building on the animal- abuse link are also part of the project."

From the BC SPCA's web site: http://www.spca.bc.ca/link/default.htm
According to a US study, 71% of pet-keeping women who enter protective care report their partner threatened, abused or killed a family animal.

The BC SPCA along with the Victim Services Division of the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General, the BC/Yukon Transition Houses, BC Veterinary Medical Association and the BC Institute Against Family Violence have launched an innovative program to increase awareness about the animal-human violence link and to promote more effective cross-reporting between law enforcement, animal care and social service agencies in British Columbia

The information will be distributed through brochures and workshops in the hope of bringing a broad public awareness to the issue. The goals are to create a procedure for cross reporting by all agencies involved and to provide a refuge and protection solution for the pets of women and children seeking the safety of a transition house.

Three brochures have been developed to be widely distributed by organizations helping victims of violence. Each brochure is targeted toward a different audience. One is for animal care professionals, the second is for victim service workers and judicial personnel and the third if for victims of abuse, to encourage them to use the support services available to them. (*See links below for the downloadable/printable PDF versions of these brochures)

The project also includes joint workshop training. Participants of several BC agencies and organizations dealing with violence on the front lines (both animal and human violence) will attend regional workshops to learn more about the link and to share information on identifying signs of abuse. From this they will create a procedure of cross-reporting that will enable victims to receive attention and prevent further violence.

Here is What the SPCA is REALLY Doing

Posted By: Jeri-Lyn Ratzlaff, Jennifer Dickson and Judy Stone: AAS
Date: Tuesday, 25 May 2004, at 5:47 p.m.

We decided to put the BC SPCA's Violence Link Project to the test. We waited three months from the time of the press release, to give the program a chance to get up and running, then we phoned all the organizations included in the list of partners on the project. We did this in February of 2004 and were not surprised to learn that in every case the BC SPCA had no real support in place for victims of violence. There were no foster homes available for the pets of abuse victims. We were consistently told by SPCA Head Office and branches that we checked with that it didn't "have the resources". All the BC SPCA could offer was for the victim to surrender their pet to the SPCA (and an unknown fate), or in some cases, the victim could pay the SPCA to board their pet. When we informed the partners in the project of this, most were shocked and surprised, and some were a little angry.

We generously waited another three months before posting our findings, in the hopes that given six months from the date of the press release, the BC SPCA would have the program up and running, and that victims of violence would by now be able to turn to the Society for the help it claims to give, but alas, the results were the same.

Here are our findings when we telephoned the list of partners:

1. VictimLink...1-800-563-0808 We phoned Feb. 28 2004. VictimLink is located in Vancouver. They have no SPCA brochures. They told us to phone the SPCA emergency line at 879-7343.

May 18, 2004 we phoned again. They know of no SPCA program to help victims with placement or fostering of their animals. They reported that the SPCA would accept an animal but that one would have to pay. We asked if payment was boarding fees, but the person we spoke to was unsure.

2. BCSPCA...1-800-665-1868 We phoned Feb 19, 11:30 a.m. and spoke to Peter. This is a head office phone number. We said that a friend was in an abusive relationship: that her partner was violent to her, the children and the dog. We asked what the SPCA can do for her. Peter told us that all they can do is take her dog if she surrenders it. No, the SPCA does not have a list of transition houses that take animals. We can get a pamphlet on violence at any SPCA. No, the SPCA does not have any resources for dealing with violence toward families and animals as it is a non-profit organization and does not have the resources. (Note: there is no guarantee that a surrendered dog won't be killed or sold to a bad owner, so of course women are very reluctant to take advantage of the SPCA's generous offer.)

Feb 23/04 We phoned the SPCA emergency number, and were told that the SPCA does not provide board or fostering to the pets of women escaping violence. Suggested that we ask a friend, board, or put in day care, or surrender.

May 18, 2004 we phoned Head Office again and were told again by Peter that the SPCA has "no resources" to help the animals of victims of abuse. We were given two options: board our dog at the West Vancouver SPCA boarding facility (we were told that if we explained our dilemma we MIGHT receive a reduced rate) or surrender our dog to the SPCA, where it would be put up for adoption. We asked whether the SPCA had a list of transition houses that accept pets, and were told no, they didn't, and that we should phone a transition house and ask them.

3. BCVMA...1-800-463-5399 www.bcvma.org This site has no search function and we couldn't find anything by browsing. We phoned and spoke to Gwen (Feb 19, 11:45 a.m.) who told us that the SPCA will foster pets until the owner can take them back. She was very surprised when we told her that they will only take surrendered pets. The BCVMA has its own glossy pamphlet, but no list of transition houses that take pets and no fostering program.

May 18, 2004 phoned again. This time the person answering had no idea at all who would be able to help.

4. BC Institute Against Family Violence...1-877-755-7055 www.bcifv.org On this site we only found four-year old material, so the SPCA has been spinning this one for a long time. Feb 23/04 Spoke to the Referral Co-ordinator who told us that the SPCA will foster dogs and to phone it or the BC/Yukon Society of Transition Houses.

May 18, 2004. We phoned the BC Institute Against Family Violence and spoke to Jenny, who was "disturbed" to hear that the BC SPCA had offered us only surrender or board for our dog. She told us that this was not the first time that someone had told her that the SPCA would not foster their animal while they sought temporary refuge. Jenny stated that it was everyone's understanding when the organizations (BC SPCA, BC VMA, BC Society of Transition Houses, and BC Institute Against Family Violence) collaborated to produce the program and pamphlet that the BC SPCA would provide free temporary care for the animals of abuse victims. She was markedly upset to hear that this was not in fact happening, stating "Well there's something not right there, that's not how it was supposed to work." She then gave us the number for the BC SPCA 's Education Department in the hope that it could shed some light.

5. BC/Yukon Society of Transition Houses...604-669-6943 www.bcysth.ca. May 18, 2004.   Spoke to the Office Manager who did not have a list of transition houses that take animals and did not know much about the Violence Link Project. There may only be one transition house in the lower mainland that takes pets.

We also tried phoning a few transition houses not located in Vancouver, just to see what they could tell us about SPCA availability.

In Victoria:
Victoria Women's Transition House: SPCA not considered a resource. Their resources are Greater Victoria Animal Crusaders for vaccines and Central Victoria Animal Hospital for two weeks free board.

Hill House Transition House: SPCA is not considered a resource. Their resources are Greater Victoria Animal Crusaders for vaccines and Central Victoria Animal Hospital for two weeks free board.

Sandi Merriman House: SPCA is not considered a resource. Their resources are Greater Victoria Animal Crusaders for vaccines and Central Victoria Animal Hospital for two weeks free board. Nana Foundation sometimes boards.

We can only conclude that the Violence Link Project is just another exercise in SPCA media spin. The brochures, the press releases, the claims of partnership and work-shopping and sharing with the community...all are part of what the BC SPCA seems to do best - promoting itself for its own benefit. The victims of violence and their pets are still left up the creek without a paddle.

Where is the Compassion? SPCA Spokesperson Lorie Chortyk Implies that a Victim of Violence Lied.
Jeri-Lyn Ratzlaff, Jennifer Dickson, and Judy Stone, AAS -- Tuesday, 25 May 2004, at 6:24 p.m.
Kamloops SPCA Employee Equates Women Who Are Victims of Violence With Criminals
Jeri-Lyn Ratzlaff, Jennifer Dickson, and Judy Stone: AAS -- Tuesday, 25 May 2004, at 6:41 p.m.
We Can Only Conclude That the Violence Link Project is Another Example of SPCA Spin Doctoring
Jeri-Lyn, Jennifer Dickson, and Judy Stone: AAS -- Tuesday, 25 May 2004, at 6:48 p.m.
if these transition houses and official women's support groups knew that there really wasn't anything being done by the BCSPCA, they would be more inclined to create something themselves
Emma Vandewetering -- Tuesday, 25 May 2004, at 8:43 p.m.
Thank you AAS. You're saving the public from being fooled again.
Hiroko Nakagawa -- Thursday, 27 May 2004, at 5:24 a.m.

Letter from Veterinarian, Dr Ellen Guttormson

Posted By: AAS
Date: Tuesday, 9 December 2003, at 11:09 a.m.

In Response To: Addressing the Link Between Family Violence and Animal Cruelty (AAS)

In regard to this subject there has just been a very interesting situation at the Victoria SPCA. I was contacted by Carol Sonex of Greater Victoria Animal Crusaders. She had just dealt with a situation whereby a woman going into a shelter for abused women needed immediate placement for her 2 cats. She contacted the Victoria SPCA and was told that they were full, could not take the cats, and the only assistence they could offer would be to put the cats to sleep. She managed to get in touch with GVAC and they made arrangements to pay for the vaccine upgrades and the cats are being boarded at the Central Victoria Veterinary Hospital at no charge. So much for all of the brochures and hoopla re caring for animals in potentially abusive situations. I forwarded the information from Carol to Craig Daniell over a week ago and have had no reply. I told him that this was one of the final straws and that I will be resigning from the CAC of the Victoria SPCA.
Ellen Guttormson

Addressing the Link Between Family Violence and Animal Cruelty
AAS -- Monday, 24 November 2003, at 6:37 p.m.
An excellent start SPCA: The only part missing is the ACTION step
Carol Sonnex -- Monday, 24 November 2003, at 6:42 p.m.
Action requires effort.... *LINK*
Gail Moerkerken -- Monday, 24 November 2003, at 7:43 p.m.
In my jaded opinion, it would have given the SPCA more credibility if ...
Jeri-Lyn Ratzlaff -- Tuesday, 25 November 2003, at 2:26 p.m.
I saw Eileen Drever last night on TV showing a dog and a cat
Hiroko Nakagawa -- Wednesday, 26 November 2003, at 8:25 a.m.
My letter to the Courier re the BC SPCA's latest p.r. "Addressing the Link Between Family Violence and Animal Cruelty "
Jeri-Lyn Ratzlaff -- Thursday, 27 November 2003, at 7:17 a.m.
If the BC SPCA is going to advertise its concern perhaps it should consider how it looks when it shows absolutely none
Carol Sonnex -- Sunday, 30 November 2003, at 7:50 a.m.
Messages Posted Between
7 May 2002 and 15 July 2008
    42 of 11,531 Messages Displayed
(Reversed Chronological Listing)
Messages Containing All of the Keywords:
violence, link, project

 

Debbie Goodine has one of the toughest jobs at the BC SPCA, by Kathi Travers *LINK*
Gail Moerkerken -- Monday, 26 May 2008, at 8:42 p.m.
Tribe of Heart: Biggest U.S. animal conference sells out to the meat industry *LINK*
AAS -- Saturday, 5 April 2008, at 9:57 a.m.
The Chronicle Journal- northern dogs
Gail Moerkerken -- Friday, 12 October 2007, at 1:51 p.m.
The SPCA's Violence Link Project *LINK*
AAS -- Saturday, 13 May 2006, at 10:57 a.m.
Women escaping violence were promised those spaces for their pets!
Lyn MacDonald -- Saturday, 25 March 2006, at 8:59 p.m.
A STRATEGIC PLAN FOR THE BRITISH COLUMBIA SOCIETY FOR THE PREVENTION OF CRUELTY TO ANIMALS 2006 to 2008
AAS -- Wednesday, 8 February 2006, at 5:29 p.m.
WHO DID WHAT IN THE HURRICANE KATRINA—RITA CRISIS? Animal People News *LINK* *PIC*
AAS -- Wednesday, 16 November 2005, at 5:44 p.m.
Animal Welfare Certificate Program: is this course required for SPCA employees? *LINK*
AAS -- Thursday, 26 May 2005, at 4:24 p.m.
Do they? Don't They? Foster pets for victims of violence
Lyn MacDonald -- Saturday, 26 March 2005, at 10:06 p.m.
Wither the SPCA?
AAS -- Friday, 18 March 2005, at 9:07 a.m.
I asked first and foremost for honesty and what did the SPCA do?
AAS -- Sunday, 13 March 2005, at 9:37 a.m.
Animal Welfare Certificate Program: is this course required for SPCA employees? *LINK*
Pat Bentley -- Monday, 28 February 2005, at 8:11 a.m.
AAS comments - point by point *PIC*
AAS -- Saturday, 26 February 2005, at 3:46 p.m.
Tracking the BC SPCA's Violence Link Project. More abuse heaped on abused women
AAS -- Sunday, 21 November 2004, at 2:51 p.m.
Three years after branch amalgamation for consistency and still no consistency
AAS -- Friday, 29 October 2004, at 10:36 a.m.
AAS letter to Larry Cardy of the Canadian Public Relations Society
AAS -- Saturday, 4 September 2004, at 10:34 a.m.
AAS letter to the BC SPCA Board of Directors: fire Craig Daniell and Lorie Chortyk before they destroy the SPCA
AAS -- Friday, 3 September 2004, at 8:30 a.m.
The BC SPCA's P.R. mistress defames and insults the Mayor and Council of Delta
AAS -- Thursday, 2 September 2004, at 9:47 p.m.
It has come to our attention that the Salt Spring Island SPCA branch no longer has a spay/neuter/assistance program
Lyn MacDonald -- Monday, 30 August 2004, at 9:49 p.m.
THE THIRD LAWYER'S ATTACK ON AAS BY THE BC SPCA
AAS -- Sunday, 29 August 2004, at 12:01 p.m.
Powell River SPCA fosters pets of violence victims *LINK*
AAS -- Thursday, 19 August 2004, at 2:44 p.m.
Victimized women and children do not deserve to be further victimized by "spin-doctored" propaganda
Carol Sonnex -- Wednesday, 18 August 2004, at 8:05 a.m.
I submitted my name as a volunteer willing to provide foster care for pets of families fleeing violent situations. As of today,I have not received one call
Gail Ferraro -- Tuesday, 17 August 2004, at 2:58 p.m.
Whoever Val McWillims is, she has obviously never checked her "facts" nor has she or anyone she knows, ever had to beg the SPCA for help
AAS -- Monday, 16 August 2004, at 11:00 p.m.
How timely - more SPCA lies about the Violence Link Project just arrived
Gail Moerkerken -- Monday, 16 August 2004, at 10:56 p.m.
Nothing is being done in BC: Unmasking the SPCA's Violence Link Project *LINK*
AAS -- Monday, 16 August 2004, at 10:43 p.m.
Re: The Violence Link Project: VanCity Newsletter Spring 2003
Gail Ferraro -- Tuesday, 3 August 2004, at 9:38 p.m.
The Violence Link Project: VanCity Newsletter Spring 2003 *LINK*
Pat Bentley -- Monday, 2 August 2004, at 4:06 p.m.
The BC SPCA fails animals and victims of violence when the hand it claims to extend is actually a closed fist *LINK* *PIC*
Gail Ferraro -- Thursday, 22 July 2004, at 9:51 a.m.
SPCA's Violence Link Project: More proof that it is a scam
Sherry Buttnor, Victoria Cat Rescue Corps Society -- Monday, 19 July 2004, at 9:15 p.m.
The SPCA's Violence Link Project exposed as non-existent except as p.r !
AAS -- Monday, 12 July 2004, at 10:30 a.m.
SAGE Transition House on the North Shore accepts pets with women fleeing violence, but no help from the SPCA
Maureen Gabriel, North Shore Crisis Services Society -- Monday, 12 July 2004, at 10:24 a.m.
SAGE Transition House on the North Shore accepts pets with women fleeing violence
Maureen Gabriel -- Sunday, 11 July 2004, at 8:36 p.m.
After saying that Cheech lunges at children's throats, the SPCA's spinmistress may have spun herself right out the door
AAS -- Thursday, 8 July 2004, at 8:12 a.m.
Animal welfarists in Victoria totally REJECT the bringing of the DTA4 tool to Victoria now and in the near future.
Carol Sonnex -- Wednesday, 7 July 2004, at 9:13 a.m.
The SPCA's Violence Link Project is "pure baloney" says former SPCA director *LINK*
AAS -- Sunday, 30 May 2004, at 8:42 p.m.
We Can Only Conclude That the Violence Link Project is Another Example of SPCA Spin Doctoring
Jeri-Lyn, Jennifer Dickson, and Judy Stone: AAS -- Tuesday, 25 May 2004, at 8:48 p.m.
The Violence Link Project: Here is What the SPCA is REALLY Doing
Jeri-Lyn Ratzlaff, Jennifer Dickson and Judy Stone: AAS -- Tuesday, 25 May 2004, at 7:47 p.m.
The SPCA's Violence Link Project: Helping Victims of Violence? It Sounds Good on Paper But is the SPCA really DOING Anything?
Jeri-Lyn Ratzlaff, Jennifer Dickson, Judy Stone: AAS -- Tuesday, 25 May 2004, at 4:15 p.m.
I saw Eileen Drever last night on TV showing a dog and a cat
Hiroko Nakagawa -- Wednesday, 26 November 2003, at 10:25 a.m.
In my jaded opinion, it would have given the SPCA more credibility if ...
Jeri-Lyn Ratzlaff -- Tuesday, 25 November 2003, at 4:26 p.m.
Addressing the Link Between Family Violence and Animal Cruelty
AAS -- Monday, 24 November 2003, at 8:37 p.m.