German agriculture minister voices 'great reservations' about cloned food
PR-inside.com
2008-01-17
BERLIN (AP) - Germany's agriculture minister said Thursday that he would have ‘great reservations’ about introducing meat and other products from cloned animals, despite a U.S. assessment that it would be safe. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration said Tuesday that food products from cloned animals are safe to eat.
The decision came after a preliminary European Union study, released last week, said such products were unlikely to pose a risk.
German Agriculture Minister Horst Seehofer said he has ‘extremely great reservations’ from an ethical point of view about bringing cloned animals into the food chain. He argued that it should not be discussed purely as a scientific or health issue, and stressed that, as a matter of ethics, he views it with ‘very great skepticism, bordering on rejection.’
The issue offers ‘a typical example of the fact that society cannot and should not put into practice everything that technically is possible,’ said Seehofer, who also is responsible for consumer protection.
EU officials on Wednesday assured consumers and critics that meat and milk from cloned animals was not about to appear on European shelves. The 27-nation union has only just launched consultations on whether to allow cloned food into the food chain, and says no decision is imminent.
The U.S. agency's six-year study concluded that meat or milk from successfully cloned animals which by definition carry the same DNA as the original are no different from the products of traditionally bred livestock.
_______________________________
Berlin Agrees On New GM Labeling Law -- But How Strict Is It?
Publication: Deutsche Welle
Date: Thursday, January 17, 2008
With a view to creating greater transparency for consumers, Germany is to introduce a special label for food that has not been genetically modified, such as products from animals that have not been fed biotech grains.
Deputy Agriculture Minister Gert Lindemann said the new "non-GM" label will apply not only to non-genetically-modified crops but to eggs, meat and milk from animals that were raised without biotech feed.
For the last four years, German food manufacturers have had the option of labeling food containing traces of GM technology, although few have made use of it because of legal uncertainties. Officially, the certificate could only be used if gene technology was absent from the entire production process -- milk from a cow, for example, which had been treated with medicine manufactured using genetically modified micro-organisms could not be labeled GM-free.
The Bundestag, Germany's parliament, is expected to approve the law next week, allowing it to be introduced in spring.
Watchdogs approve
Bildunterschrift: Großansicht des Bildes mit der Bildunterschrift: Consumers demonstrate for the right to choose
Consumer watchdogs have hailed the move as a pragmatic solution. They say it provides farmers with greater motivation to avoid using genetically modified products such as corn and soya. In the past, they were more likely not to go to the trouble, since they knew they would not be allowed to use the non-GM label anyway.
"The new labeling will give consumers the choice to buy dairy products from animals that have not been fed with genetically modified plants," said Gerd Billen from the Federation of German Consumer Organizations in Tuesday's Süddeutsche Zeitung newspaper.
"In future, the consumer will be in a position to make a political decision not to support gene technology in agriculture," agreed Thilo Bode from Foodwatch in the same article.
Experts also say that a rise in consumer demand for food carrying the new label might lead to an increase in demand for non-GM feed on the international market.
Misleading consumers?
Bildunterschrift: Großansicht des Bildes mit der Bildunterschrift: The new labels will improve transparency
However, food that is manufactured using genetically modified ingredients such as additives, vitamins and amino acids can be marked with the new labeling.
This has prompted Germany's opposition to dismiss the proposed label as misleading, even though genetically modified additives may be used only when there is no alternative, they must comply with the EU's organic regulations and may no longer contain any genetically modified micro-organisms.
"This is a sneaky frontal attack on consumers and farmers who want to consume and produce non-GM products," said Renate Künast from the Green party.
The move was announced in Berlin on Sunday, Jan. 13, the same day the US said it would temporarily hold fire on sanctions on European Union goods in a last-ditch attempt to resolve a bitter trade dispute over genetically modified crops.
The EU missed a World Trade Organization deadline Friday to comply with a decision against EU restrictions on some genetically modified organisms.
http://www.agbios.com/main.php