I am totally against BYB, puppy mills, brokers etc. I just wouldn't want to see anyone that is a genuine breeder, breeding for the betterment of the breed, to be put on a list clasifying them as a BYB. If everyone that posts an add is listed as a BYB or puppy mill then people are going to get confused as to who is a good breeder and who isn't and buy the first dog they come across that they like the looks of.