Animal Advocates Watchdog

Mr. Daniell believes that killing seized animals as collateral damage is an acceptable method of cruelty prevention

Mr. Daniell is quoted in Barbara Yaffe's column as saying that seized animals "are better off dead than living in such environments (as they were seized from) or spending their lives in a cage."

Heaven help the animals that the SPCA picks to seize for its next round of media grandstanding. In the past year alone Mr. Daniell has overseen the seizure of well over a thousand animals. Included in these seizures were over one hundred of Sylvia Rutledge's livestock and exotics, that were given back to her for $5,000 and Karen Raffles' eleven puppy mill dogs that were given back to her for $11,000.

Port Alberni Lhasa Apso breeders, who kept all their dogs in the house, only crating some at night (an accepted practice of animal management according to the Canadian Veterinary Medical Association's standards, which the BC SPCA endorses) had all their dogs seized and thrown into SPCA cages in the name of cruelty prevention. Two of their pups contracted Parvovirus while in SPCA care and died.

Thompson Okanagan puppy miller J.R. Pyke surrendered over 30 of his most neglected breeding dogs to the Kamloops SPCA in an attempt to avoid being raided. Kamloops SPCA warehoused the dogs, and despite many offers to foster, began killing them as the dogs were so terrified in their SPCA cells that they were unable to pass SPCA scientific assessment tests.

Mr. Daniell said these words to me last fall at an SPCA meeting: "If I seize one hundred dogs and I have to kill ten, I still consider that seizure to be a success." So essentially what Mr. Daniell told me is that he believes in collateral damage.

Taking an animal from a familiar cage only to stuff it into a strange cage is not cruelty prevention. Mr. Daniell is deluded if he thinks that most SPCA facilities are more humane than the average breeding kennel. There really is no difference. Breeders warehouse dogs and sell the offspring, SPCAs warehouse seized breeding dogs and either sell them or kill them if they fail scientific assessment tests. There is almost no humane rehabilitation and many offers of help from individuals and private rescue organizations are ignored. The seized are exploited via the media for donations, then all too often are killed or sold back to the abusers. They are collateral damage, and Mr. Daniell approves.

The SPCA shows no promise of reform under Mr. Daniell's direction. Its latest press release is proof that it is still more interested in marketing itself than restructuring itself to serve animals. Its latest press release regarding the conviction of Beaverdell dog breeder Gaston Lapointe is full of misinformation and misleading figures, designed to make the reader think that the SPCA did right by Mr. Lapointe's dogs. I am staggered at the gall of a Society that seems to presume that no one is watching.

Messages In This Thread

A prison camp for animals: Barbara Yaffe on the BC SPCA
Tired of SPCA excuses
Why would the SPCA not have statistics on how many animals are euthanized???
SPCA p.r.: "The animals in our care receive veterinary attention when needed".
Recently a Richmond SPCA employee "dropped" a rabbit, breaking its jaw in five places
Animal care guidelines are closely monitored?
Just to name a few of the more memorable examples of the BC SPCA’s duplicity
Write The Sun
The blunder that will not die
The tragedy is that countless animals died unnecessarily
SPCA - forget blaming the public for not "respecting and caring" for its animals
SPCA misplaces the blame for its own ethical shortcomings on the public
SPCAs are worse than concentration camps: One cat is saved out of thousands *PIC*
Daniell said shelters in some parts of B.C. are "wanting," but would not compare any to a concentration camp
The SPCA cries poor every chance it gets, but what IS it spending its millions on?
Daniell said shelters in some parts of B.C. are "wanting," but would not compare any to a concentration camp
BC SPCA CEO Craig Daniell rebuts
Blaming the public while setting the wrong example for the public to follow
The SPCA can do better!
First Craig Daniell says the SPCA has no euthanasia statistics, then he says BC SPCA has one of the lowest rates in North America
Some assistance for Mr Daniell's euthanasia count
At least it's not 75,000 a year anymore
Lorie Chortyk can help Daniell with his body count: According to her the SPCA only kills 1% of dogs
Today the BCSPCA employees over 30 administrative and provincial staff and yet they're suddenly too busy and overworked to provide these stats to their members and the public?
For the public: others should bear responsibility. For real: the SPCA kills instead of accepting offers from rescue
The rescue community has extended our hand multiple times to help the animals and sadly the SPCA refuses
Do they give out educational material when someone adopts a cat or dog in English, as well as other languages?
Mr. Daniell believes that killing seized animals as collateral damage is an acceptable method of cruelty prevention
More SPCA PR Lies: SPCA Press Release: Kelowna Man at Center of High Profile Animal Cruelty Case Pleads Guilty *LINK* *PIC*
Animals are worse off after being seized for "cruelty" BY the SPCA!
AAS has the file on the incident of the Christmas Terrier. Yaffe's facts are straight and here are some more *PIC*
More women are defying the SPCA's ever-ready lawyers
SPCA Should Be Tried for Animal Abuse
More "have not" branches now than before restructuring
More SPCA PR Lies: SPCA Press Release: Kelowna Man at Center of High Profile Animal Cruelty Case Pleads Guilty *LINK* *PIC*
All we know for sure is that the SPCA sure took care of the dead part *PIC*
Clutching at straws to justify killing: Giardia is easily treatable *LINK*
Is this how the BCSPCA takes care of problem employees?
Classic SPCA! They don't know the dog is pregnant and the SPCA has Parvo! *PIC*
Mr Daniell would get more sympathy if....
Barbara Yaffe points out discrepancies in Daniell's statements that AAS pointed out too *LINK*
The whole story of how the Surrey SPCA killed so many dogs because of easily treatable kennel cough *NM* *LINK*
Big Heart Rescue met with Craig Daniell to ask questions on April 16th: Still no answers
"Mistakes" are endemic at the chaotically-run BC SPCA. The BC SPCA historically was easy to run...

Share