Animal Advocates Watchdog

Three letters: Is this "speaking for animals?"

The Sun
Editor,

Once again an animal pays the ultimate price because of human interference and dominance. Adding further insult to this tragedy, the SPCA, proclaiming itself to be "dedicated to protecting and enhancing the quality of life" now says that it "was prepared to destroy the animals if the pens weren't improved to make them safe." Something's terribly wrong if this is considered to be "speaking" on animals' behalf.

Gangus was betrayed, a victim of our system, of our society, and of "human nature." Now he's dead, killed, not protected.

Carmina Gooch
North Vancouver

Vancouver Sun
Editor,

Our relationship with the other animals of this planet is appalling. Here it is, the 21st century, and we are still acting like barbarians. Now the SPCA, an agency whose job it is to speak for and to protect our animals admits that they were prepared to destroy the tigers if conditions weren't improved. Never mind that the incident hadn't even yet occurred.

The casualness and subsequent decision to kill Gangus demonstrated a total lack of respect not only for his life, but for all the endangered tigers.

Terry Roberge
North Vancouver

Editor, The Sun

The increased market for exotic/wild animals will most likely result in more tragedies if the provincial government doesn't take a leadership role, as promised. Wild animals, like these big cats, do not belong in captivity. They are wild. Taken from a natural environment and penned in tiny enclosures is downright cruel.

Regarded as novelty items, exploited as entertainment or for financial gain, and deprived of freedom, is against all that's right. Mr. Carlton was on the radar, yet once again we have the blame game, and by all accounts, a preventable double tragedy.

Animal welfare matters, so does public safety, and wherein there's power, there lies responsibility, so rather than excuses by the SPCA and all levels of government, how about some action so we don't have a repeat of this situation?

Carmina Gooch
North Vancouver

Messages In This Thread

Tiger Kills Woman – Time for Government Ban on Exotic Animals *LINK*
100 Mile House: captive tiger mauls woman
Washington bans wild animals as pets
Whistler bar boasts that it will have sex, wine, and tigers *LINK*
AAS received three phone calls from very upset people who witnessed the exploitation of this tiger and a lynx at Burnaby's Brentwood Mall *LINK* *PIC*
Why did the Burnaby SPCA permit the mall show? Did the SPCA report the unsafe enclosures to the Ministry of Social Services?
Why didn't the SPCA make Carlton build an adequate shelter?
Tiger to be destroyed
Am I mis-reading this? "The other two tigers in the compound will be kept alive."
Lifeforce Foundation on CKNW: Peter Hamilton actually does more than pose for the media
I hope a coroner's investigation looks into all the chances the SPCA had for so many years to do something
Pictures of the tiger's cage?
Office of the Premier responds to concerns
Whoever ordered Gangus's "euthanasia" should be charged.
Pictures of the tigers in their miserable cage *PIC*
Brave children battled killer tiger
The SPCA would kill the tigers even when they had done nothing wrong? Where is that in the SPCA's mandate?
There appears to be a lot of confusing contradictions *PIC*
Which is it? You COULD seize or you COULDN'T seize?
The SPCA spent thousands of dollars trying to find new lodging for the tigers
Letters to Editors
Tragic tiger mauling highlights need for exotic-pet controls
Vancouver city councillor wants provincial ban on exotic pets
Three letters: Is this "speaking for animals?"
Vancouver City Council votes to raise the issue at the next UBCM meeting
There is absolutely no excuse good enough to warrant SPCA leaving these exotic animals in this horrific state
2002: Tigers kept in cage under porch in Abbotsford
Canadian Press: Marcie Moriarty, general manager of cruelty investigations for the SPCA, said the facility is a "public safety catastrophe."
One of the tigers escaped in 2002: Abbotsford law in 2003 - a long history of complaints

Share