Animal Advocates Watchdog

Lies, damned lies, and statistics

Statistics are notoriously untrustworthy. AAS is bombarded with statistics from pit bull defenders that "prove" that Cockers bite more than Pit bulls do for example.

Perhaps they do. That would likely be because they are represented in the dog population 20 or 30 times as much as Pit bulls are. But the only relevant point is that Cockers can't be blamed for fatal or maiming attacks, and it is fatal and maiming attacks that society must protect itself against, not Cocker spaniels. Bites are something that society is prepared to live with.
What matters to society is the number of severe bites and fatal bites, and pit bulls, in their tiny numbers, are responsible for as much as 25% of those.

All the fatal dog bite statistics we have read over the last few years contradict each other. One example: From a partisan Pit bull defender's web site http://ncrf2004.tripod.com/:

1997: 20 deaths, 4 by Pit bulls 20% (Pit bulls represent 1% or less of the dog population)

From the US Department of Health and Human Services: http://www.cdc.gov/ncipc/duip/dogbreeds.pdf

1997: 18 deaths, Pit bulls and Rottweilers 50+%

There isn't time to find all the contradictions, so we don't quote statistics much, but the fact that the Pit bull isn't even on the American Kennel Clubs list of 50 most popular breeds for 2000, yet it accounts for as many as 25% of fatal attacks, is hard to ignore. Our criteria for believing that Pit bulls are disproportionally dangerous, is a commonsense conclusion based on several factors. One, that even pit bull defenders say they have a high prey drive, something that makes any dog dangerous. Two, that the serious, unprovoked attacks in our province are almost always by Pit bulls or Pit bull crosses. Three, that even Pit bull rescuers can't have more than one or two pit bulls or they will kill each other, or kill the other dogs in the family. Four, that Pit bulls are genetically selected for fighting, and are equipped with huge, powerful jaws, and with powerful musculature. And four, that I don't know any honest person who, if confronted with a Cocker spaniel running toward them, or a Pit bull running toward them, wouldn't be much more fearful of the Pit bull, and that includes Pit bull defenders.

The AKC list for 2000
Labrador retriever
Golden retriever
German shepherd
Dachshund
Beagle
Poodle
Yorkshire Terrier
Chihuahua
Boxer
Shih Tzu
Rottweiler
Pomeranian
Miniature Schnauzer
Cocker spaniel
Pug
Shetland sheepdog
Miniature pinscher
Boston terrier
Siberian husky
Maltese terrier
Bulldog
Basset Hound
Doberman pinscher
German pointer
Bichon Frise
English Springer spaniel
Welsh corgi
Great Dane
Pekinese
West Highland white terrier
Brittany spaniel
Weimaraner
Lhasa Apso
Collie
Australian shepherd
St. Bernard
Shar-pei
Akita
Mastiff
Cairn terrier
Chesapeake Bay retriever
Scottish terrier
Papillon
Chow chow
Great Pyrenees
Airedale terrier
Vizsla
Alaskan Malamute
Dalmatian
Bloodhound
USA- http://www.enchantedlearning.com/subjects/mammals/dog/popular.shtml

Messages In This Thread

The Tyee: Banning of the Pit Bulls *LINK*
It is a perversion of love to defend the suffering that most pit bulls endure.
Controls that weren't necessary in the past, are now necessary.
It is absolutely heart wrenching watching these poor dogs in shelters
Your article is the best I have ever read on this subject
It was inherently wrong to have dogs fight animals in the first place
Working with good pitbulls makes it difficult to make me want an outright ban
Big Heart Rescue's postion
Re: Big Heart Rescue's postion
Animal fighting is against the Criminal Code and of course the SPCA can go on reserves to investigate it!
A political analyst stated that a govt only makes decisions that reach 4 yrs ahead to the next election
I've been haunted by many TV screen images of pitbulls
What is meant by the word "ban"?
Lies, damned lies, and statistics
The Pit Bull Queen shows her colours - Diane Jessop says it's all a plot! Even anti-tethering laws
Re: The Pit Bull Queen shows her colours - Diane Jessop says it's all a plot! Even anti-tethering laws
Pit Bull advocacy group condems tethering *LINK*
Bad Dogs :why some breeds of dogs are more likely to attack people
Presa Demand Grows for All Wrong Reasons: Dogs wanted for killing, fighting
Toronto Star: Attorney-general sticks to his guns - Criminals are drawn to pit bulls
Dogs being used as weapons right here!
Pit bull fighting in the U.S.
Sun newspaper ads for Cane Corsos
Local Presa Canario/Pit bull breeder

Share