Animal Advocates Watchdog

Question 14: What needs to change at the BC SPCA before it ruins its reputation irrevocably?

Question 1: Why didn't the BC SPCA tell the Prince Rupert SPCA last year not to boil crabs in the future?

Question 2: Why hasn't the BC SPCA Board of Directors ever adopted a policy of not using some cooked species of animals to raise money?

Question 3: Will the SPCA tell the many branches that are holding the annual Paws of a Cause fundraisers in September not to serve meat in the future, starting this year?

Question 4: The SPCA has also justified roasting dogs and chopping up live turtles as "culturally acceptable". The SPCA keeps repeating that it is an animal welfare agency. How can any real animal welfare agency make such a statement?

Question 5: When first told that some people were objecting to the crab feast, Ms Chortyk justified it by saying that her authorities assured her that crabs feel no pain. Why would the BC SPCA not know that that has not been scientifically established?

Question 6: Has Ms Chortyk or any of the Management or Members of the Board of Directors of the BC SPCA ever watched crabs being boiled and seen how frantic they are to escape the heat?

Question 7: If any of them have, why would that not be enough to make them stop allowing crabs to be boiled alive?

Question 8: Why would it take the threat of world-wide condemnation and the threat of a loss of money for the SPCA to stop boiling crabs alive?

Question 9: Why has the SPCA only stopped doing things to animals that shock and horrify real animal welfarists (historically and even now), if the level of harm to its reputation (which translates into financial harm) reaches a significant point?

Question 10: Why is the BC SPCA still in the dog-catching/disposal business? If it were the best dog-catcher in BC, that could be some small justification. But in fact, where the SPCA has been replaced as the poundkeeper (Langley, North Vancouver District, Coquitlam, Delta, etc) the level of animal welfare has improved at those pounds. We say "could" be justification, but in fact, because of the requirement for pounds to seize and destroy dogs deemed dangerous, no real animal welfare agency ought to take money to do this. This ought only to be the duty of municipalities.

Question 11: Why is the SPCA still intaking more animals than it can rehabilitate and rehome, knowing that it is going to kill a percentage of them? This is especially true of cats which inevitably sicken in confined catteries such as the SPCA's.

Question 12: Why does the biggest animal organization in North America (the BC SPCA's claim) lag decades behind in real animal welfare policies?

Question 13: The BC SPCA not only does not lead animal welfare, it does not even follow. Other animal welfare organizations long ago set the example by adopting policies of cruelty-free fundraising. The BC SPCA has gone on selling cooked animals - the products of cruel factory farming - at its fundraisers. The SPCA historically has only budged if it is in its best interests - not because of the best interests of animals or of furthering a culture of compassion. Selling cooked animals supports, entrenches, and legitimizes a culture of thoughtless cruelty. Why is the BC SPCA still setting an example of thoughtless cruelty in the year 2006?

Question 14: What needs to change at the BC SPCA before it ruins its reputation irrevocably?

Messages In This Thread

The SPCA is boiling crabs alive again *LINK* *PIC*
Is refusing to boil animals alive just more of that disreputable "animal rights advocates" nonsense?
Incompatible with respect for life
SPCA not living up to its name
Is the BC SPCA content with saying the right thing, but not doing the right thing?
Civilization is another word for respect for life
I spy an oxymoron
Sea Shepherd Society's Paul Watson's message to the SPCA: Some People Just Don't Get it!!!!!!
An animal welfare organization? I don't see how they have the gall to use that term
People will do most anything for money and this certainly proves the point
Shame on this Animal Helfare Society! *LINK*
Looking forward to the follow-up P.R.
Remember the old bumper sticker, "Nuke a Gay Whale for Jesus"?
I am shaking my head....
For once in my life I am speechless
It has long bothered me that some SPCA fundraisers have taken the form of hot dog sales and BBQs
Crab Boil: Vancouver Sun: BC SPCA's P.R. person says it's up to the branch to decide
Ms Chortyk is strangely uninformed
Will the BC SPCA start a legal action for defamation against Paul Watson of the Sea Shepherd Society? *LINK*
After last years crab boil, why didn't the Board of Directors adopt a cruelty-free fundraising policy?
The Province: Environmental group protests charity event
Crab Boil is cancelled
Someone had better tell Ms Chortyk
Hallelujah for public pressure!
I urge you to have strictly vegetarian fund-raisers at all branches, at all times
SPCA denies that crabs feel pain in spite of learned opinion
Crabs have two main nerve centers, one in their front and one to their rear, and—like all other animals who have nerves and an array of other senses *LINK*
Prince Rupert SPCA cancels crab boil after public outcry
These basic questions beg careful consideration.
Contravening own policies for money
SPCA crab feast led to bomb threat, says RCMP
SPCA interview on As It Happens
Question 14: What needs to change at the BC SPCA before it ruins its reputation irrevocably?
I'm left with a sick feeling that, if they could have got away with it, they would have
Boiling crabs is antithetical to SPCA's raison d'etre
Rafe Mair weighs in with comment
Paul Watson - The SPCA: they just don't seem to understand the contradictions
I buy a crab to set it free
All beings are sentient. All beings suffer. All beings 'feel' that suffering
Barry Faires is being sued by the BCSPCA *NM* *LINK*
"Food for Thought" helps SPCAs to see the contradictions between rescuing some animals — and eating others! *LINK*
Vancouver Sun: Petition to stop the SPCA from serving animals to raise money to "prevent cruelty"
Questioning the statement, "The SPCA does a lot of good work. Who else would take in the homeless cats and dogs?"
Anyone concerned about the hyprocrisy of grilling some animals in order to prevent cruelty to others should approach their local shelters in order to help steer them in a humane veggie direction
Boiling crabs? Not funny! *NM* *PIC*

Share