Animal Advocates Watchdog

Vancouver Sun: Petition to stop the SPCA from serving animals to raise money to "prevent cruelty"

Your Vancouver Sun

Animal rights groups urge meat ban at SPCA events
Society accused of hypocrisy for barbecued meat at fundraisers

Nicholas Read, Vancouver Sun
Published: Wednesday, August 23, 2006

Energized by their success in Prince Rupert last week where they convinced the local SPCA to cancel a fundraising event that involved boiling live crabs, animal-rights activists now want the B.C. SPCA to ban the serving of meat at all society fundraising functions.

"This is prime time to ask the SPCA to revisit their own policies to do with fundraisers, and to roll out a new policy that would work towards events that would not involve the killing of animals," said Sinikka Crosland, president of The Responsible Animal Care Society, an Okanagan-based animal-protection group.

Crosland, who was instrumental in organizing an online campaign against a proposed Aug. 27 crab cook-off to benefit the Prince Rupert branch, said it was hypocritical of the SPCA -- an organization that seeks to prevent cruelty to all animals -- to condone the intensive farming and killing of animals for meat by serving it at fundraising events.

"The SPCA does a lot of good work," she said. "Who else would take in the homeless cats and dogs? That needs to be said. However, I think they need to go beyond that. This is not just about dogs and cats; it's about factory-farmed animals too."

The Canadian Voice for Animals, a North Shore-based animal-protection group, has posted an online petition demanding an end to all SPCA fundraising events that involve the serving and consuming of meat.

"We, the undersigned, join the Canadian Voice for Animals and its co-sponsors in condemning the B.C. SPCA and its branches for blatantly condoning the eating of other animals to raise money to help save dogs and cats and all cuddly animals," it says.

"We demand that all fundraising events that have animal products on the menu be stopped once and for all."

It says fundraising barbecues are planned in Kamloops, Penticton, Vernon, Powell River, Surrey, Squamish, Campbell River, Comox, Grand Forks and 100 Mile House.

Craig Naherniak, general manager of humane education for the B.C. SPCA, said vegetarian choices are often available at SPCA fundraising events, and that branches "are moving in that direction."

However, he said it was not B.C. SPCA policy to force branches to discontinue cooking and serving meat. That was a matter for individual branches to decide on their own.

"Each individual makes choices as to how they think they can make an impact," Naherniak said. "As the organization progresses, people become more critical of their food choices. I see in the foreseeable future that we will have people in the branches ready to make that step."

In the meantime, he said he hoped branches would serve SPCA-certified products -- eggs, chicken, beef and dairy products -- where possible. SPCA-certified meat has been raised according to a set of humane standards.

The Sea Shepherd Society, which organized the campaign against the Prince Rupert SPCA crab boil, is not involved in the current campaign, though society founder Paul Watson said he supports it.

nread@png.canwest.com

- - -

THE PETITION

We, the undersigned, join www.canadianvoiceforanimals.org, and its co-sponsors in condemning the B.C. SPCA and its branches for blatantly condoning the eating of other animals to raise money to help save dogs and cats and all cuddly animals. We demand that all fundraising events that have animal products on the menu be stopped once and for all.
Animal rights groups urge meat ban at SPCA events
Society accused of hypocrisy for barbecued meat at fundraisers

Nicholas Read, Vancouver Sun
Published: Wednesday, August 23, 2006

Like all who love animals, it is difficult to understand what part of the words Cruelty To Animals that the SPCA doesn't understand.

While we've had confirmation that the Prince Rupert branch cancelled the crab boil slated for August 27th because of bad public relations, they still have plans for several up-and-coming fundraising events.

The statement can be found at www.canadianvoiceforanimals.org
© The Vancouver Sun 2006

Messages In This Thread

The SPCA is boiling crabs alive again *LINK* *PIC*
Is refusing to boil animals alive just more of that disreputable "animal rights advocates" nonsense?
Incompatible with respect for life
SPCA not living up to its name
Is the BC SPCA content with saying the right thing, but not doing the right thing?
Civilization is another word for respect for life
I spy an oxymoron
Sea Shepherd Society's Paul Watson's message to the SPCA: Some People Just Don't Get it!!!!!!
An animal welfare organization? I don't see how they have the gall to use that term
People will do most anything for money and this certainly proves the point
Shame on this Animal Helfare Society! *LINK*
Looking forward to the follow-up P.R.
Remember the old bumper sticker, "Nuke a Gay Whale for Jesus"?
I am shaking my head....
For once in my life I am speechless
It has long bothered me that some SPCA fundraisers have taken the form of hot dog sales and BBQs
Crab Boil: Vancouver Sun: BC SPCA's P.R. person says it's up to the branch to decide
Ms Chortyk is strangely uninformed
Will the BC SPCA start a legal action for defamation against Paul Watson of the Sea Shepherd Society? *LINK*
After last years crab boil, why didn't the Board of Directors adopt a cruelty-free fundraising policy?
The Province: Environmental group protests charity event
Crab Boil is cancelled
Someone had better tell Ms Chortyk
Hallelujah for public pressure!
I urge you to have strictly vegetarian fund-raisers at all branches, at all times
SPCA denies that crabs feel pain in spite of learned opinion
Crabs have two main nerve centers, one in their front and one to their rear, and—like all other animals who have nerves and an array of other senses *LINK*
Prince Rupert SPCA cancels crab boil after public outcry
These basic questions beg careful consideration.
Contravening own policies for money
SPCA crab feast led to bomb threat, says RCMP
SPCA interview on As It Happens
Question 14: What needs to change at the BC SPCA before it ruins its reputation irrevocably?
I'm left with a sick feeling that, if they could have got away with it, they would have
Boiling crabs is antithetical to SPCA's raison d'etre
Rafe Mair weighs in with comment
Paul Watson - The SPCA: they just don't seem to understand the contradictions
I buy a crab to set it free
All beings are sentient. All beings suffer. All beings 'feel' that suffering
Barry Faires is being sued by the BCSPCA *NM* *LINK*
"Food for Thought" helps SPCAs to see the contradictions between rescuing some animals — and eating others! *LINK*
Vancouver Sun: Petition to stop the SPCA from serving animals to raise money to "prevent cruelty"
Questioning the statement, "The SPCA does a lot of good work. Who else would take in the homeless cats and dogs?"
Anyone concerned about the hyprocrisy of grilling some animals in order to prevent cruelty to others should approach their local shelters in order to help steer them in a humane veggie direction
Boiling crabs? Not funny! *NM* *PIC*

Share